Saturday, October 19, 2013

Perception versus Perversion of Reality?

By Colin Singer

Recently a 20 strong group of senior American Executives visited Indonesia for their first time to expand upon their education. They came from an array of industries such as car manufacturing, hospital management, realtors, and a plethora of IT businesses. I believe their first experience of Indonesia was not so different to that of many Australian executives.

On the first night at a five star hotel in Jakarta, the overwhelming topic of conversation was in regards their safety. One Indian – American was concerned that her forehead mark should be removed because it would make her a target for attack. All agreed they would not go out after dark and only as a group.

They had spent hours and many dollars being culturally and inter-faith educated prior to departing for Indonesia. Without exception the training was total rubbish; but dangerous rubbish in that the perception given by those highly reputable instructors and the USA Authorities was that Indonesia was akin to a war zone inhabited by fiercely radical Islamists. Not a place to visit and for sure a highly risky place to do business in.

The women had been told they must wear long dresses, flat shoes, and head coverings at all times. Similarly the males had been told to also wear appropriately conservative clothing. They had been indoctrinated in a myriad of exhortations to do this, do that, and definitely don’t do that! Pity the three left-handed participants who struggled to work out how they would manage even mundane challenges such as eating!

The overarching message embedded by the training was that it was better to keep a low profile and not interact with Indonesians unless essential. What a difference a day can make.

“Why are those woman wearing shorts and tight jeans?”

“Why are so few woman wearing head coverings?”

“Why is everyone smiling at us as we go by or pass them?”

A high level tour of PT Bintang (a beer brewery) had been arranged and many questions and comments revolved around just how the business managed success in an apparently beer hostile environment.

“How did Heineken set-up its first overseas brewery in Indonesia?”

“Why it has been successful for so long and how secure did they feel?”

On the university visits the execs were constantly taken aback by the number of senior female lecturers and the vibrant, enthusiastic, “happy” student population. They had been led to believe the stereotypes that all woman were subordinates- mere slaves to men’s whims. My wife was certainly surprised to hear this!

Within three days their initial paranoia had been deposed by a nocturnal excursion to the Stadium discotheque in Jakarta. Many consider it to be the largest, busiest, noisiest place, on the most inhabited island in the world. They fortunately returned relatively undamaged except for the ravages of PT Bintang’s illustrious tonic.

Although traffic and pollution were of concern, the newly converted were astonished by the mass distribution of mobiles, smartphones, IPads, not to mention biblical amounts of motorbikes. Jakarta’s gleaming hotels and malls were generally rated well above anything they had previously experienced, both in style, substance, and service.

At the end of the course one lady summed it up for all, saying all of their pre-conceptions had been “shattered”. She also vehemently complained that their baggage had proved to be 80% useless as they did not need long dresses etc. They had in fact purchased so many items they would probably have to pay excess baggage charges.

One student wrote, “I had a different perception of the country and how business was done in Indonesia. Our trip to Indonesia changed a lot of it and now I can understand why Indonesia is perceived to be among the top five best countries to do business. Indonesian people are very friendly and welcoming.”

No comments:

Post a Comment